By Roz Jones

Medicare decisions can become another responsibility caregivers are expected to understand, especially when an aging loved one starts receiving more healthcare. You may be helping review medical bills, keeping track of appointments, checking insurance statements, or trying to understand why Medicare paid one portion of a bill while your loved one is responsible for another. That is often when Medicare Supplement Insurance, also called Medigap, becomes part of the conversation.

Medigap can help with some of the out-of-pocket costs that remain after Original Medicare pays its share, but it is not a replacement for Medicare and it does not cover every healthcare expense your loved one may have. Understanding how the coverage works can help families decide whether it fits into the larger healthcare and financial plan.

Understand What Medigap Actually Supplements

Medigap works alongside Original Medicare, Part A and Part B. Medicare pays its share of covered healthcare costs first, and the Medigap policy may then pay some or all of the remaining costs covered under that particular policy.

Those remaining costs can include deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments. Without supplemental coverage, those expenses can become difficult to predict, especially for an aging loved one who sees several providers, receives outpatient services regularly, or experiences a hospitalization.

One important distinction for caregivers to understand is that Medigap is not the same thing as Medicare Advantage. Medicare Advantage is another way to receive Medicare benefits, while Medigap supplements Original Medicare. Your loved one cannot use a Medigap policy to pay the copayments, deductibles, or premiums associated with a Medicare Advantage plan.

Know What Medigap Does Not Cover

Having supplemental insurance does not mean every healthcare-related expense will be covered. Medigap policies generally do not cover long-term care, routine dental or vision care, hearing aids, eyeglasses, or private-duty nursing.

Prescription drug coverage is also separate. Medigap policies sold after 2005 do not include prescription drug coverage, so someone with Original Medicare and Medigap may also need a separate Medicare Part D prescription drug plan if they want drug coverage.

That distinction becomes especially important for caregivers because many of the services an aging loved one may eventually need are not automatically covered simply because they have Medicare and Medigap. If your loved one begins needing ongoing personal care at home, assistance with activities of daily living, or long-term nursing home care, Medigap should not be treated as a long-term care insurance policy.

Compare the Plan, Not Just the Insurance Company

Medigap plans are standardized in most states and identified by letters, such as Plan G, Plan K, or Plan N. That means the basic benefits of a particular lettered plan are generally the same regardless of which insurance company sells it.

The price may not be the same.

Two companies may sell the same lettered Medigap plan with the same standardized benefits and charge different premiums. Premiums can also vary based on where your loved one lives and other factors, and those premiums can increase over time.

For caregivers helping compare coverage, that means it is worth looking at more than the name of the insurance company. Compare the same plan letter across several companies and ask how premiums are determined and whether the company has a history of increasing rates. The lowest premium today may not always be the only factor worth considering when the coverage may be kept for years.

Pay Attention to When Your Loved One Enrolls

Timing matters with Medigap in a way families may not realize.

The federal Medigap Open Enrollment Period is generally a one-time six-month period that begins when someone has Medicare Part B and is age 65 or older. During that period, your loved one can generally buy any Medigap policy sold in their state regardless of health problems.

That period does not return every year like Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period.

After the Medigap Open Enrollment Period ends, an insurance company may be allowed to use medical underwriting when someone applies for coverage unless the person qualifies for certain guaranteed issue protections or has additional rights under state law. That can mean higher premiums, fewer options, or being denied a policy.

Caregivers should pay attention to this timeline when helping someone first transition into Medicare rather than assuming they can simply add the same supplemental coverage several years later under the same conditions.

Look at the Healthcare Your Loved One Actually Uses

Choosing coverage should begin with your loved one’s needs rather than with the plan someone else recommends.

Think about how frequently your loved one receives medical care, whether they see specialists regularly, whether they travel, what they can realistically afford each month, and how comfortable they are with unpredictable out-of-pocket expenses.

A person who rarely receives care may look at the monthly premium differently from someone managing several chronic conditions and attending frequent appointments. One family may place a higher value on predictable healthcare expenses, while another may be more focused on keeping monthly premiums manageable.

There is no single Medigap plan that is automatically right for every older adult. The goal is understanding what financial risk your loved one is trying to reduce and whether the cost of the policy makes sense within their budget.

Consider How Often Your Loved One Travels

Original Medicare generally allows someone to see any doctor or hospital in the United States that takes Medicare, which can be useful for aging loved ones who spend time in different states or travel frequently.

Some Medigap policies also provide limited coverage for emergency medical care while traveling outside the United States, which Original Medicare generally does not cover except in limited circumstances.

That does not mean a Medigap policy should automatically replace travel medical insurance. Coverage outside the United States depends on the particular Medigap plan and has limits. If your loved one travels internationally, review those benefits carefully instead of assuming all medical expenses abroad will be covered.

Remember That Plan Options Can Depend on Medicare Eligibility

Not every Medigap plan is available to every Medicare beneficiary. For example, Plans C and F are no longer available to people who became newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. People who were eligible for Medicare before that date may still have access to those plans depending on their circumstances.

Some states also have different rules for people under age 65 who qualify for Medicare because of disability or End-Stage Renal Disease. Federal law generally does not require insurance companies to sell Medigap policies to beneficiaries under 65, although some states provide additional protections or options.

This is another reason caregivers should avoid comparing coverage based only on what another family member or friend has. Your loved one’s eligibility, state, age, and Medicare history can affect what is actually available to them.

Understand What Your Loved One Will Still Pay

Medigap adds another monthly premium to the household budget. Your loved one still has to pay the Medicare Part B premium, and then they pay a separate premium directly to the private insurance company providing the Medigap policy.

Depending on the plan they choose, there may still be other out-of-pocket costs as well. In 2026, for example, Plans F and G may offer high-deductible versions in some states. Those policies require the beneficiary to pay Medicare-covered costs up to a $2,950 deductible in 2026 before the high-deductible Medigap policy begins paying. Plans K and L also have annual out-of-pocket limits, which are $8,000 and $4,000 respectively in 2026.

Caregivers should look at the entire cost picture instead of focusing only on the monthly premium. Consider what your loved one would pay each month, what expenses they could still face when they receive care, and whether those costs remain manageable alongside medications, housing, transportation, food, and other caregiving expenses.

Get Unbiased Help Before Making the Decision

Medicare can become confusing quickly because families are often comparing Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Part D prescription drug coverage, Medigap policies, employer or retiree coverage, and sometimes Medicaid at the same time.

You do not have to understand all of that by yourself.

Every state has a State Health Insurance Assistance Program, or SHIP, that provides free counseling to people with Medicare and their families. SHIP counselors are not insurance agents and are not connected to a particular insurance company or health plan. Medicare specifically recommends contacting SHIP when consumers need help comparing their options.

That can be especially useful when a caregiver wants someone to explain the differences without immediately being sold a policy.

Review Coverage as Part of the Larger Care Plan

Insurance should not be reviewed separately from everything else happening in your loved one’s life. A healthcare plan that worked when they first enrolled in Medicare may need another look as their health, finances, prescriptions, travel habits, or care needs change.

Medigap policies themselves are generally guaranteed renewable as long as premiums continue to be paid, but that does not mean families should stop paying attention to costs. Premiums may increase over time, and other parts of Medicare coverage, including prescription drug plans, may also need to be reviewed separately.

Keep insurance information with the other documents you use to manage care. Know which Medicare coverage your loved one has, which company provides the Medigap policy, how premiums are being paid, and who to contact when you have questions about a bill or claim. The more organized that information is, the easier it becomes to help when something changes.

I first talked about supplemental coverage in Unraveling the Maze of Medicare Supplemental Insurance. The basic purpose of Medigap has not changed, but caregivers in 2026 still need to understand the difference between Medigap and Medicare Advantage, how enrollment timing affects access to coverage, what supplemental policies do not pay for, and why comparing both benefits and long-term costs matters.

Prepare for Your Next Trip

Planning to travel with an aging loved one? Download the free Vacationing with an Aging Loved One Checklist to help you prepare for medications, mobility needs, comfort, safety, and unexpected changes.

Tune in to The Caregiver Café Podcast

Struggling with being patient as a Caregiver

In this episode of The Caregiver Café with Roz Jones, Roz is talking about something every caregiver has probably struggled with at one time or another: patience.

Caregiving does not happen in a perfect environment. You may wake up late, your schedule may change, something unexpected may happen with your aging loved one, or you may simply be tired, hungry, overwhelmed, and trying to get too much done at once. Before you know it, something small can push you from calm to frustrated.

And Roz will be the first to tell you—she is working on this right along with you.

In this episode, Roz breaks down six reasons we often struggle with patience, including disrupted routines, feeling like there is never enough time, comparing our progress to someone else’s, becoming overwhelmed, expecting results too quickly, and trying to function when we are tired or hungry.

Give Yourself a Moment of Grace

Caregiving includes demanding days, unexpected changes, and moments of connection that may be easy to overlook. Moments of Grace offers encouragement to caregivers who need a reminder to pause and recognize the meaningful moments along the journey.

Preparing for hurricane season?

Are you preparing for hurricane season? Purchase the Caregiver Hurricane Preparedness Checklist to organize the information and supplies your family may need before severe weather arrives.

Subscribe to The Caregiver Cafe Weekly Newsletter!